Short answer
Comparison is automatic and cannot be switched off. What you can influence is the selection and what you do with the result.
Envy points, with surprising precision, at what you want yourself but have not put into words — often something you have given up hope of.
It becomes harmful only when it is turned into bitterness: when it stops being about what you want and starts being about the other person not deserving it.
Comparison is automatic
The first thing worth knowing is that comparison is not a choice, and that all advice built on stopping it is doomed to fail.
We are social creatures, and our brain constantly measures where we stand in relation to others. That is presumably why we have survived in groups, and it runs automatically, faster than any conscious decision can intervene.
What can be influenced, on the other hand, is two things: who you compare yourself with, and what you do with the result. Both are in practice entirely in your hands, and both are more effective than trying to stop.
The selection is the easier of the two. Once you compared yourself with a roughly random group — neighbours, colleagues, relatives — containing people both above and below yourself. Now the selection is often sorted by what captures attention, which in practice means other people's best moments. More on that part here.
Salary, housing and what others can afford are among the things we compare. What research says about how much money itself matters for how we feel is in the article on money and happiness.
Why we are ashamed
Envy is the feeling people find hardest to admit: harder than anger, harder than fear, often harder than grief.
The reason is that it feels like a judgement on your character. Being angry is understandable, being sad is sympathetic — but being envious reads as petty. You are the one who begrudges someone something.
The consequence is that it is almost never said out loud, and therefore almost never examined. It is put aside, and what is put aside keeps working in the background.
That is a shame, because envy is one of the most informative emotions we have. It knows things about you that you have not yet thought.
What the feeling points to
Here is what makes it worth bringing out: you are rarely envious of random things.
You are not envious of everything someone else has. You are envious of something in particular — and that something is almost always something you want yourself, but have either not put into words or have given up hope of.
Try it. Think of the last time you felt a pang of envy. What exactly was it? Not “her life” — what? The freedom? That someone saw her? That she dared? That she had time? That she could do what she wanted without asking permission?
The answer to that question is usually a more precise description of what you are missing than anything you arrived at by thinking it through. Reason is busy with what ought to matter. Envy doesn't care about that.
It is particularly useful when it comes out of the blue — when you envy someone whose life you have no wish to live at all. Then it points to a component, and that component is worth finding out about.
Using it
1. Acknowledge it, quietly. “I am envious.” Not to the person, just to yourself. It sounds trivial, and it is the step that makes the rest possible, because a feeling you cannot admit to cannot be examined.
2. Be precise. What exactly? One word, if you can manage it. The vaguer the answer, the more likely it is that you are turning it into a story about your own worth rather than information.
3. Ask whether it can be had. Sometimes it cannot — age, circumstances, luck. Then it is grief, and grief should be grieved, not solved. But surprisingly often the answer is that it can, in some form, and that you have not thought of the idea.
4. Take the smallest possible step in that direction. Within a week. Not the plan — one thing. What happens then is that the envy loses its grip, not because you have got what you wanted but because you have stopped being passive about it.
When it has turned into bitterness
There is a point at which envy stops being useful, and it is worth being able to recognise in yourself.
Envy is about I want that. Bitterness is about she shouldn't have it. The first points forward and carries information. The second points nowhere at all.
Signs that it has tipped over: you start looking for faults in the person. You feel a small lift when something goes badly for her. You explain her success away as luck, connections, or having got it for free.
The danger with bitterness is that it feels like an analysis. It comes with arguments, it feels fair, and it protects you from having to look at your own life. But it costs more than it gives — and it shows outwardly far sooner than you think.
The way out is the same question as above, asked again: what did I want? Bitterness is usually envy that no one took seriously, least of all the person carrying it.
The most important thing
If you only take one thing with you: envy is not a flaw of character. It is a compass.
It points at what you want and have not dared to put into words. The question is not how to get rid of it, but whether you are willing to read what it is trying to say — and then take the smallest possible step in that direction.
This is chapter 23 of my book: Not Everyone Can Be the Best. The whole book is free to read here on the site.
Best wishes, Mikael GlännströmWellbeing coach, author and father of two