Short answer
More options make the choice heavier, not lighter. Every option you rule out is a loss — and the more you have, the greater the sum of what you give up.
Distinguish between maximising (finding the best, having to go through everything) and satisficing (setting criteria in advance, taking the first option that meets them). Maximisers get somewhat better outcomes and are less satisfied with them.
And what costs the most is rarely the wrong choice. It is the months when you didn't choose.
Why more choices make it worse
We grew up with the idea that more options are always better, and for the first handful that holds true. One option is worse than three.
But the curve turns, and it turns earlier than you might think. By twenty options, choosing is no longer a freedom but a job — and a job with an unpleasant feature: every thing you choose away is something you don't get.
With three options you give up two. With twenty you give up nineteen. The sum of what you forgo grows with every new possibility, and that sum is what you feel in your body as you stand there weighing.
That also explains why decisions with major consequences but few options are often easier to make than small decisions with many. Choosing between two jobs can take an evening. Choosing a sofa can take six months.
The maximiser and the satisficer
There are two ways of going into a choice, and they lead to very different lives.
The maximiser wants to find the best option. By definition, that means every option must be examined, because how else would you know? And since new options keep appearing, the work is never finished.
The satisficer decides in advance what is required and takes the first option that meets it. Not ‘the best’ — the good enough.
What research consistently points to is this: maximisers often make somewhat better decisions measured by outcomes, and at the same time they are less satisfied with them. They pay more in time and anxiety before the decision, and then keep comparing with what they gave up.
So the person who chooses a little worse often ends up with a better life from the choice. That is uncomfortable if you are someone who likes doing things properly, and it is worth sitting with.
The regret before the decision
What actually locks a decision is rarely the difficulty of comparing the options. It is imagined regret.
You simulate how it would feel to have chosen wrong, and the simulation is unpleasant enough that you postpone. Then you simulate again tomorrow.
There are two things worth knowing about that simulation. The first is that we systematically overestimate how long an outcome will affect us — both good and bad. The choice that feels like a decisive crossroads has often lost most of its charge a year later, however it turned out.
The second is that regret over what you did fades faster than regret over what you didn't do. A decision that turned out wrong can be lived with. A decision that was never made remains an open question for ten years.
Four ways to break free
1. Set the criteria before you look. Write down what is required before you start comparing. If you do it the other way round, the criteria will be shaped by the options, and then each new option can reshape them again — which is exactly why the process never ends.
2. Set a deadline and keep it. A decision expands to fill the time you give it. ‘I'll decide on Sunday’ is not arbitrary but the working tool: it makes the question finished rather than open.
3. Make the decision smaller. Can you try it? Rent rather than buy? Take it for three months first? A reversible decision does not demand the same certainty, and much of the weight lies in the notion that it is final — which it often isn't.
4. Ask what you would advise a friend. Almost everyone knows the answer straight away when the question is put that way, and almost no one trusts it when it comes to themselves. That is not because you lack judgement, but because fear of regret interferes with access to it. The question removes that interference.
If you choose wrong
Then you do. It happens to everyone, and it is rarely as bad as it felt beforehand.
Most decisions can be adjusted. Most outcomes fade. And you will never find out how the other option would have turned out, which means the comparison you are afraid of can't even be made afterwards — you will only be able to imagine it, and imagination always picks the more beautiful version.
What is rarely possible to get back is time. Six months of weighing is six months, and it doesn't appear in any column when you count the pros and cons.
The most important thing
If you take away one thing: decide what is required before you look at what is available.
Nearly all decision anxiety comes from criteria being shaped by the options rather than the other way round. If you have the criteria first, the choice becomes a filter, and filters are quick. If you don't, it becomes a comparison of everything with everything — and that never finishes.
This is chapter 25 of my book: Too Many Choices. The whole book is free to read here.
Best wishes, Mikael GlännströmWellbeing coach, author and father of two