Short answer
Shyness is a personality trait. Social anxiety is a condition that steers your choices.
The shy person finds it uncomfortable at first and then warms up. The person with social anxiety avoids, reviews themselves for hours afterwards and builds their whole life around situations to be avoided. The difference, then, is not how much it feels — it is what it costs.
Symptoms of social anxiety
1177 Vårdguiden (Sweden's national healthcare advice service) describes social anxiety, formerly called social phobia, as strong discomfort in certain social situations, with worry about being scrutinised or making a fool of yourself. The body often reacts with a racing heart, dry mouth, blushing, cold sweats or dizziness. And the more you avoid what you fear, the stronger the anxiety gets, according to 1177.
Four differences that matter
Calling social anxiety 'being very shy' is understandable, and it is also what can make you put off seeking help. Here is what actually separates them.
1. Avoidance
Shyness affects how you are in a room. Social anxiety affects which rooms you walk into. If you turn down jobs, courses, parties and conversations you actually wanted to have, then it is no longer a personality trait but something that makes decisions for you.
2. Attention turned inwards
In the middle of a conversation the shy person is absorbed in the conversation. The person with social anxiety is absorbed in themselves: am I blushing, do I sound odd, what do I look like right now. You are, in effect, in two conversations at once, and one of them is an inspection.
This is also why it tends to get worse the harder you try. All the attention going into monitoring yourself is not going into listening, and you come across as absent in exactly the way you feared.
3. Replaying afterwards
The hours afterwards, when the conversation is replayed line by line, with particular attention to anything that might have been misread. Often in bed, often for several days, sometimes for years — there is often a collection of embarrassments from school that can still be replayed in full colour.
Shyness doesn't do that. This part is almost the most exhausting, and the one people are most ashamed to admit to.
4. The safety behaviours
All the small things that are meant to make the situation safe: rehearsing the sentence in your head before you say it, holding the glass so your hands don't visibly shake, sitting nearest the door, talking a little too much or not at all, having a ready excuse to leave early.
They feel like solutions. In fact they are the fuel — but that needs a heading of its own.
Why safety behaviours keep the fear alive
A safety behaviour does two things. It lowers the discomfort right now — and it makes sure you never find out what would have happened without it.
If the evening goes well because you had two beers beforehand, prepared three topics to talk about and left after an hour, then the brain doesn't learn 'it went well'. It learns 'it went well because I did all that'. The conclusion is that the situation is still dangerous, and next time the same package is needed again.
That is why someone can go to a hundred dinners and still be exactly as frightened of the hundred-and-first. It is not exposure if the protection comes along.
What helps
What has the best evidence for social anxiety is cognitive behavioural therapy (CBT), and three parts do most of the work. 1177 describes the same thing: CBT with gradual exposure to what you fear, with medication of the SSRI or SNRI type as an alternative. Healthcare prescribes it.
Going into the situation — without the safety behaviours. Not the hardest thing first. A ladder: something that causes moderate discomfort, done enough times for it to become undramatic, and only then the next step. The point is not to get through it without anything, but to stay until the body notices that nothing happened.
Turning attention outwards. An exercise that sounds too simple to work: decide in advance to find out three things about the person you are talking to. As long as your attention is directed outwards it cannot at the same time monitor you, and you can feel the difference the first time you try.
Testing the prediction rather than arguing about it. 'Everyone will notice that I'm shaking' is not an opinion to argue away, but a prediction that can be tested. What exactly do you think will happen? How would you notice it? Then you do it and compare. It is uncomfortable, and it is that part that actually shifts something.
One thing that often needs saying: stopping avoidance does not mean becoming outgoing. The aim is not for you to love mingling. The aim is for you to be able to choose.
Having been through it myself
I have had social phobia, and what I remember most clearly is not the difficult situations but the planning around them — how much of a week could go on working out how to avoid something without it showing.
Today I live without strong anxiety, and I regularly stand in front of halls with hundreds of people. Not because the fear never comes, but because it no longer gets to decide. It is the only difference I would promise anyone: not that it disappears, but that it stops being the one that chooses.
Why a group is often the right format
It sounds like the worst possible thing, working on social anxiety in a group. That is also why it works so well: the group is the exercise itself, in a format where everyone knows what the others are struggling with.
I run a group coaching course for social anxiety online, with a small number of participants and the camera optional at first. If you would rather start on your own, that works just as well — personal coaching is 60 minutes, online or in person in Lindesberg.
When care is what's needed
Social anxiety disorder is a condition that can be diagnosed, and you are entitled to CBT through the health service — start at the local health centre (vårdcentralen) or 1177 (Sweden's national healthcare advice service). If there is depression, suicidal thoughts, or drinking that has grown into a way of coping with the anxiety, care is the right route, and 112 if it is urgent. If you are having thoughts of not wanting to live: call Självmordslinjen 90101 (Mind's suicide helpline), open around the clock, or chat via mind.se.
Coaching is not treatment. Here is the difference in detail, including the times when the answer is that you should not book me.
The most important thing
If you only take one thing with you: the question is not how uncomfortable it feels. It is what it costs you.
Shyness costs a few minutes at the start of a party. Social anxiety costs jobs, friendships and evenings you have already decided not to go to. That difference is what decides whether it is a personality trait or something to do something about.
Kind regards, Mikael GlännströmWellbeing coach, author and father of two
