Short answer
Self-confidence is about what you can do: trusting that you will manage a task. It is specific to each area — you can have great self-confidence in the kitchen and none at all in a meeting.
Self-esteem is about what you are worth, regardless of performance. It is not specific to any area, and it cannot be built up by getting better at things.
That is why someone can be high-achieving, well regarded and skilled — and still feel they aren't good enough. It is not a contradiction. It is two different systems.
1177 Vårdguiden (Sweden's national healthcare advice service) describes it the same way: self-esteem is the value you feel you have, and self-confidence can be strong while self-esteem is weak.
Why the difference matters
Advice about "boosting self-esteem" is often in fact about self-confidence: set goals, achieve them, collect evidence that you can. It works well — on self-confidence.
On self-esteem it often does nothing at all, and sometimes the opposite. Someone who builds their worth on evidence needs new evidence all the time, and a single failure brings the whole structure down. It is the same mechanism as in perfectionism.
A simple test of which of the two is chafing: how does it feel when you do something badly? "That went badly, I need to practise more" is self-confidence. "I knew I wasn't good enough" is self-esteem.
If you want to go a little further than one question, there is a self-assessment test on self-esteem and self-confidence with twelve statements. It is a reflection exercise, not a diagnosis.
How to build self-confidence and self-esteem separately
Self-confidence. Self-confidence grows from practice at the specific thing. 1177 advises you to pick a manageable task that feels challenging but that you know you can handle. My own suggestion is to break it into small steps, do it often enough for it to feel ordinary, and write down what actually went well. That makes better self-confidence something you can show yourself, area by area.
Self-esteem. Self-esteem is not strengthened by more evidence. 1177 suggests asking yourself what you would have said to a friend in your situation, and saying it to yourself when you catch yourself judging yourself. It also helps to take your own needs seriously: eating properly, sleeping enough, moving and planning in things you feel good doing. The rest of the way, values, relationships where you don't have to perform, and the inner voice, is described in the next section. Source for the advice in this section: 1177 Vårdguiden (Sweden's national healthcare advice service) on self-esteem.
If you want to know which of the two chafes most, there is the self-assessment test. And if you want the topic as a talk for a workplace, school or association, there is the talk on self-esteem and self-confidence.
What self-esteem is actually built from
Not from praise. Praise is pleasant, but it runs off anyone who doesn't already believe it — it is dismissed as politeness, or as luck that they haven't seen through you.
Why other people's approval is so rarely enough, and what happens when it becomes the measure of your worth, is covered in the article on the need for validation.
Three things do more:
1. Doing things that match what you consider important. Self-esteem grows from acting in line with your values, especially when nobody sees it. Someone who shows up for another person without that person knowing gets something no achievement gives. This is the core of ACT.
2. Being seen for something other than your performance. A relationship where you are not the one delivering, performing or fixing things. It is hard to arrange on your own.
3. Stopping taking the inner voice seriously. The inner voice is not a judge with access to the truth. It is a habit formed by what you have heard and experienced before. The difference between "I'm not good enough" and "I have the thought that I'm not good enough" is the whole difference.
Three misconceptions
"You should love yourself." For someone who doesn't, it sounds like one more demand to fail at. A more reasonable aim: stop being your own worst enemy. Neutral is good enough, and far more realistic than being in love with yourself.
"Self-esteem comes from success." There are plenty of successful people with poor self-esteem. If success built self-esteem, there would be none of them.
"You have to fix your self-esteem first, and then you can live." It is the other way round. It is built from what you do, not from what you have concluded about yourself. If you wait to feel worthy before doing something you want, you will wait forever.
What you can do this week
Do one thing a day that matches your values. Small. Ring a friend who has had a hard time. Speak up when someone is treated unfairly. It doesn't have to be visible.
Notice how you talk to yourself, for three days. Just notice. It can make uncomfortable reading — you would never speak like that to anyone else.
Try the uncomfortable question. If a friend described exactly your situation and said exactly what you say about yourself — what would you answer? And why doesn't that answer apply to you?
Stop comparing your inside with everyone else's outside. You know all of your own doubts and none of anyone else's. It is not a fair comparison, and it is the comparison that social media is built on.
When it is more than low self-esteem
If you think you are worthless most of the time, feel no joy, or think other people would manage better without you — then it is not self-esteem but possibly depression, and that is treatable. Your local health centre (vårdcentral) or 1177 Vårdguiden (Sweden's national healthcare advice service), and 112 if it is an emergency. If you are having those thoughts: call Mind Självmordslinjen 90101 (Mind's suicide helpline), open around the clock, or chat via mind.se.
How I work with it
In personal coaching we don't work on convincing you that you are good enough — that cannot be argued into place. We work on two things: acting in line with what you consider important, and turning the inner voice into something you hear rather than something you are.
The chapter Dare to be yourself in the book takes the same theme, and if it is mostly about performance, there is the article on perfectionism.
The most important thing
If you take away just one thing: you cannot perform your way to self-esteem. It is the one area in life where more effort doesn't help.
What helps is duller and slower: doing what you think is right, often enough, until it becomes harder to claim that you aren't worth anything.
Warmly, Mikael GlännströmWellbeing coach, author and father of two
